| Collegiate Cross Country Runners | ||
| Greg Cashman | Tim Nesbitt | Ken Lucas |
| Ohio University | University of Mount Union | Tiffin University |
| Plymouth Class of 1964 | Plymouth Class of 1972 | Plymouth Class of 1975 |
 |
 |
 |
| Eliot Fackler | Evan Fackler | Libby Fackler |
| College of Wooster | Earlham College | College of Wooster |
| Plymouth Class of 2000 | Plymouth Class of 2006 | Plymouth Class of 2009 |
 |
 |
 |
| Mitchell McKenzie | Stephanie Grube | Matthew McKenzie |
| Mount Vernon Nazarene University | Marietta College | Mount Vernon Nazarene University |
| Plymouth Class of 2010 | Plymouth Class of 2012 | Plymouth Class of 2015 |
 |
 |
 |
| Daren Gies | Nathaniel Redden | Michael Collins |
| Defiance College | Ashland University | Malone University |
| Plymouth Class of 2015 | Plymouth Class of 2017 | Plymouth Class of 2019 |
 |
||
| Levi Robinson | ||
| Cedarville University | ||
| Plymouth Class of 2021 | ||